The short version
- You may not need anyone. If the free playbooks fix your problem and you have the time, do them yourself.
- If you do hire help, ask to see evidence: the exact questions, the dates, the tools and the sources.
- Walk away from anyone who guarantees a ranking or an AI mention, or who offers fake reviews or hidden tricks.
Do you need help at all?
Plenty of this work is within reach of a business owner: checking what AI says, cleaning up listings and handling reviews. Doing it yourself costs time rather than money.
Help tends to be worth paying for when you don't have the hours, when you've done the basics and nothing has moved, or when you want someone to re-test every month and tell you what changed. That's our opinion, and we do sell this work, so weigh it accordingly.
What GEO means
GEO stands for Generative Engine Optimization: making sure AI assistants describe your business accurately and include it in their answers. It builds on the basics of good SEO, and Google says its AI features don't need special optimizations beyond those basics. Be wary of anyone selling it as a separate secret method.
What a useful audit should include
Ten questions to ask
Ask these on any sales call, including one with us. A good provider should be happy to answer them.
Questions for any agency
1. Can I see a sample report? Does each finding show the date, the tool and the exact question? 2. Which questions will you test, and can I see and change them? 3. How many times do you run each question, and on which AI tools? 4. Do you guarantee a ranking or a mention? (The honest answer is no.) 5. What exactly will you do each month, and what will I get to see? 6. How do you handle reviews? Do you ever offer incentives or ask only happy customers? 7. Will anything be posted under my name without my approval? 8. Who owns my listings, logins and content if I stop paying? 9. What do you do that I couldn't do myself from free guides? 10. Does a person check the findings, or is the report entirely automated?
Red flags
- Guaranteed rankings or AI mentions. AI answers change from run to run, so nobody can honestly promise this.
- Fake or paid reviews. Google removes them, and Canada's Competition Bureau treats misleading reviews as a legal risk.
- Review gating. It breaks Google's rules, even when software presents it as "reputation management".
- Hidden text or instructions aimed at AI tools. If they're found, your reputation pays for it.
- A single magic fix. Be wary if someone presents
llms.txtor a special schema as the answer. Google says neither is needed for its AI features. - A one-off screenshot as proof. One answer on one day shows very little. Ask for a dated record over several runs.
- Keeping your logins or listings. Your Google profile and domain should stay in your name.
- Secrecy about the questions. If you can't see what's being tested, you can't judge the results.
How we answer these
You should hold us to the same list. Every engagement starts with evidence, a person checks each finding, we draft review replies for you to approve and post, and we never promise a ranking or a mention. Our prices are published on our site so you have a reference point. We're a new agency, and we'd rather you compare us with other options than take our word for it.
How sure are we?
- Sure: Google's rules on fake and incentivized reviews, and its position on AI features, read on the date below.
- Our opinion: the audit list, the questions and most of the red flags. We sell this kind of work, so keep that in mind.
Sources
- Google Search Central: AI features and your website, read 2026-10-31.
- Google: fake engagement policy, read 2026-10-31.
- Competition Bureau: Deceptive Marketing Practices Digest, volume 1, read 2026-10-31.