The short version
- On Google you can ask for genuine reviews, but you have to ask everyone, without offering anything in return.
- On Yelp, don't ask at all. Yelp's own rules say not to.
- Reply calmly, be specific, and never share a customer's details. Hand threats and legal claims to a lawyer.
- Time
- About 30 minutes to set up (our estimate)
- Cost
- Free
- You need
- Your Google review link
- You end up with
- A request and replies ready to use
The rules, in plain English
| Where | Can you ask? | What's not allowed |
|---|---|---|
| Yes, for genuine reviews | Paying or giving discounts or free goods for reviews, including to change or remove a bad one. Asking only happy customers. Discouraging negative reviews. | |
| Yelp | No. You can say "Find us on Yelp", but don't ask for a review | Asking customers, friends or your mailing list for reviews, or offering anything for them. Reviews that look prompted may not count toward your rating. |
| Canadian law | Honest reviews are fine | Fake or misleading reviews. Staff reviewing their own employer without clearly saying so. The Competition Bureau warns that a business can be liable for reviews it writes or allows. |
Asking only happy customers is called review gating. A common version sends a private survey first and only sends people to Google if they were pleased. Don't do this, even if software offers it as a feature.
Dentists, physicians and other regulated health professionals: check with your College before asking patients for reviews. Ontario's dental college lists testimonials as prohibited in advertising. The physicians' college warns that directing patients to post reviews could be a problem.
How to ask every customer
The simplest honest system is to send the same message to every customer, at the same point in every job. If it isn't automatic, tie it to something you already do, such as sending the final invoice.
- Find your review link. Google gives you one to share inside your Business Profile.
- Pick when you'll send it, such as the day after the job.
- Send it to everyone, including the job that went badly.
Text message
Hi [first name], it's [your name] at [business]. Thanks for having us out. If you have a minute, would you leave an honest review of how it went? Good or bad, it helps us and the next customer: [link]. Reply STOP and I won't text you about this again.
Subject: How did we do? Hi [first name], Thanks for choosing [business] for [the job]. If you have a minute, would you leave an honest review of how it went? Good or bad, it helps us improve and helps the next customer decide. [link] Thanks, [your name] [business] · [mailing address] · [phone] If you'd rather not get messages like this, reply and let me know.
Canada's anti-spam law, CASL, can apply to texts and emails. It generally requires consent, your business details and a way to unsubscribe. A recent purchase usually gives you implied consent for a limited time, but check how it applies to you. This isn't legal advice.
How to reply
- Be specific. Mention something real from the review so it doesn't read like a template.
- Never share details. That means no address, job price, health information or anything else the customer didn't post. Don't confirm they're a customer in a sensitive business, such as a clinic.
- Don't argue in public. Say what you can and offer a direct way to talk.
- Never offer anything for changing or deleting a review. Google's rules prohibit it. You can still make a real problem right, as long as it isn't tied to the review.
Good review
Thanks, [first name, if they show it]. Glad [the job] went well, and it's good to hear [specific thing they praised]. I'll pass that on to [team member or the team].
Mixed review
Thanks for the honest feedback. Glad [what went right] worked out. [What went wrong] isn't what we aim for, and we've [what you actually changed]. If you'd like to talk about it, I'm at [phone]. [Your name], owner.
Bad review, real problem
I'm sorry about [the problem, in general terms]. That's not the standard we hold ourselves to. I'd like to look into it and put it right. Please call me directly at [phone]. [Your name], owner.
You can't find the customer
We take this seriously, but we can't match it to a job from the details here. Please call [your name] at [phone] so we can look into it.
When not to reply
Stop and get advice before replying to anything involving:
- a threat, or something that could be defamation;
- a regulator, an insurer or a lawyer;
- an injury, or a health or safety incident.
A careless reply can make these worse. If a review looks fake or breaks the platform's rules, report it through the platform's own tools. Don't post a counter-review or ask friends to pile on.
Why this matters for AI
EVIDENCE 2026-10-23 · Google AI Mode and logged-out ChatGPT · 9 Ontario HVAC and plumbing businesses, names left out
Wording from Google reviews and profiles sometimes turned up in AI Mode's answers. ChatGPT often repeated review counts from third-party sites, and they were frequently out of date.
More reviews didn't always mean more mentions. We saw a business with 42 reviews named far more often than a neighbour with 111, so treat reviews as one signal among several.
Your reviews also matter to the person reading them, before any AI gets involved. A fair reply to a bad review can say more about how you run things than ten good ones.
How sure are we?
- Sure: the rules above come from Google, Yelp and the Competition Bureau, read on the date below. They change, so check the source.
- Less sure: how reviews affect AI answers. Our tests are small.
- Our opinion: the templates and the timing advice. We're not lawyers, and none of this is legal advice.
Sources
- Google: fake engagement policy, read 2026-10-31.
- Yelp: "Don't Ask for Reviews", read 2026-10-31.
- Competition Bureau: online reviews posted by employees, January 2024, read 2026-10-31.
- Competition Bureau: Deceptive Marketing Practices Digest, volume 1, read 2026-10-31.
- CRTC: frequently asked questions about Canada's anti-spam legislation, read 2026-10-31.
- RCDSO: Advertising Guidelines, read 2026-10-31.
- CPSO: Advice to the Profession, Advertising, read 2026-10-31.
- Our own checks of Ontario trades, 2026-10-23. Business names are left out.